Edward Colston/Trans rights/Stamp collecting

1212224262769

Comments


  • Perhaps they could release the video evidence of it being there last October, eight months before the garage being allocated?
    Or they could see if pulling it does actually move the garage door?
  • rick_chasey
    rick_chasey Posts: 75,661


    Perhaps they could release the video evidence of it being there last October, eight months before the garage being allocated?
    Bit disappointed you never answered who you thought the display of solidarity was calling tensions between.
  • ballysmate
    ballysmate Posts: 15,930


    Perhaps they could release the video evidence of it being there last October, eight months before the garage being allocated?
    Bit disappointed you never answered who you thought the display of solidarity was calling tensions between.
    Tbh I thought it would've been obvious.
    After several high profile cases involving excessive use of force against the black population by US law enforcement agencies, the drivers publicised this as another racially motivated incident.
  • rick_chasey
    rick_chasey Posts: 75,661


    Perhaps they could release the video evidence of it being there last October, eight months before the garage being allocated?
    Bit disappointed you never answered who you thought the display of solidarity was calling tensions between.
    Tbh I thought it would've been obvious.
    After several high profile cases involving excessive use of force against the black population by US law enforcement agencies, the drivers publicised this as another racially motivated incident.
    I was confused because I was struggling to see anyone who would be opposed to the show of solidarity other than racists, which is why I wanted to tease out the answer.
  • veronese68
    veronese68 Posts: 27,813
    Do the other garages have similar ropes to shut the doors?
  • tailwindhome
    tailwindhome Posts: 19,436

    Do the other garages have similar ropes to shut the doors?

    Yes they do.
    But they look somewhat different

    “New York has the haircuts, London has the trousers, but Belfast has the reason!
  • surrey_commuter
    surrey_commuter Posts: 18,867

    Do the other garages have similar ropes to shut the doors?

    Yes they do.
    But they look somewhat different

    I could not class those as ropes
  • veronese68
    veronese68 Posts: 27,813
    Rope or not, if the only one tied into a noose is in the garage of the only black driver it seems to be a little more than coincidence.
  • DeVlaeminck
    DeVlaeminck Posts: 9,104
    In the UK I wouldn't really associate a noose with lynching but it'd be understandable if that is the association in the southern states of the USA.

    Let's be honest - if that's the case and the latest photo is genuine that has been done with racist intent even if it wasn't to target Bubba (I'm not on first name terms just can't remember his second name - was going to say Watson but got a feeling that's a golfer!).

    The original picture was from a distance and looked a bit less noose like - but then being from a distance it's not enough to say it's not the same knot/noose.
    [Castle Donington Ladies FC - going up in '22]
  • surrey_commuter
    surrey_commuter Posts: 18,867

    Rope or not, if the only one tied into a noose is in the garage of the only black driver it seems to be a little more than coincidence.

    my point was that Bubba's noose had not been fashioned from an existing "rope pull" which suggests that it was not unthinking idle hands.
  • surrey_commuter
    surrey_commuter Posts: 18,867

    In the UK I wouldn't really associate a noose with lynching but it'd be understandable if that is the association in the southern states of the USA.

    Let's be honest - if that's the case and the latest photo is genuine that has been done with racist intent even if it wasn't to target Bubba (I'm not on first name terms just can't remember his second name - was going to say Watson but got a feeling that's a golfer!).

    The original picture was from a distance and looked a bit less noose like - but then being from a distance it's not enough to say it's not the same knot/noose.

    coincidentally this popped up on my FB feed which does a good job of explaining to likes of us the continued significance of the noose

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mYYDgYWc3lE
  • nickice
    nickice Posts: 2,439

    Rope or not, if the only one tied into a noose is in the garage of the only black driver it seems to be a little more than coincidence.

    But it had been there for months according to the FBI so that would mean it was there on the off chance he'd one day use the garage And see if a racist person did it (unlikely) it's hardly surprising that there are racists in a country of 350m. The response of the other drivers shows racists aren't welcome.

    Yet another BS racism story just like Jussie Smollett.
  • kingstongraham
    kingstongraham Posts: 28,152
    edited June 2020
    nickice said:

    Rope or not, if the only one tied into a noose is in the garage of the only black driver it seems to be a little more than coincidence.

    But it had been there for months according to the FBI so that would mean it was there on the off chance he'd one day use the garage And see if a racist person did it (unlikely) it's hardly surprising that there are racists in a country of 350m. The response of the other drivers shows racists aren't welcome.

    Yet another BS racism story just like Jussie Smollett.
    Woah there - it is NOT like Jussie Smollett.
  • nickice
    nickice Posts: 2,439

    In the UK I wouldn't really associate a noose with lynching but it'd be understandable if that is the association in the southern states of the USA.

    Let's be honest - if that's the case and the latest photo is genuine that has been done with racist intent even if it wasn't to target Bubba (I'm not on first name terms just can't remember his second name - was going to say Watson but got a feeling that's a golfer!).

    The original picture was from a distance and looked a bit less noose like - but then being from a distance it's not enough to say it's not the same knot/noose.

    Maybe someone is just immature? When I was in Scouts someone fashioned a rope into a noose.
  • kingstongraham
    kingstongraham Posts: 28,152


    That seems an entirely mature way of dealing with it. I think we can all agree that it did look quite noose-y.
  • blazing_saddles
    blazing_saddles Posts: 22,725
    edited June 2020
    Who knew? The Church of All Saints are not so saintly when tying up their bell ropes. ;)






    How's this for a bit of graphic symbolism? :D


    "Science is a tool for cheaters". An anonymous French PE teacher.
  • kingstongraham
    kingstongraham Posts: 28,152
    I see no noose there.
  • rick_chasey
    rick_chasey Posts: 75,661

    Who knew? The Church of All Saints are not so saintly when tying up their bell ropes. ;)






    How's this for a bit of graphic symbolism? :D


    Sorry, what was the point of this?
  • kingstongraham
    kingstongraham Posts: 28,152
    edited June 2020
    The traditional tying would have the rope looped back around itself 13 times. Not normally used like that though.

    What you have in those pictures is traditionally called "not a noose".
  • rick_chasey
    rick_chasey Posts: 75,661
    The whole "ah, but this symbol out of context doesn't mean the same thing as the symbol in context, so people who are offended by the symbol in context are stupid" argument is so weird.

    Why are you making that point?
  • rjsterry
    rjsterry Posts: 29,550
    edited June 2020

    Who knew? The Church of All Saints are not so saintly when tying up their bell ropes. ;)






    How's this for a bit of graphic symbolism? :D


    FFS. That's clearly not a noose. It's a very distinctive knot. If you are going to troll, put some effort in.
    1985 Mercian King of Mercia - work in progress (Hah! Who am I kidding?)
    Pinnacle Monzonite

    Part of the anti-growth coalition
  • DeVlaeminck
    DeVlaeminck Posts: 9,104
    edited June 2020
    nickice said:

    In the UK I wouldn't really associate a noose with lynching but it'd be understandable if that is the association in the southern states of the USA.

    Let's be honest - if that's the case and the latest photo is genuine that has been done with racist intent even if it wasn't to target Bubba (I'm not on first name terms just can't remember his second name - was going to say Watson but got a feeling that's a golfer!).

    The original picture was from a distance and looked a bit less noose like - but then being from a distance it's not enough to say it's not the same knot/noose.

    Maybe someone is just immature? When I was in Scouts someone fashioned a rope into a noose.
    But were your scouts in the southern states of the USA?

    It may have been immature but assuming the noose does have a different significance over there - which seems a reasonable assumption - it's still a racist act albeit one done out of immaturity rather than some strongly held racist views.
    [Castle Donington Ladies FC - going up in '22]
  • nickice
    nickice Posts: 2,439
    edited June 2020

    nickice said:

    In the UK I wouldn't really associate a noose with lynching but it'd be understandable if that is the association in the southern states of the USA.

    Let's be honest - if that's the case and the latest photo is genuine that has been done with racist intent even if it wasn't to target Bubba (I'm not on first name terms just can't remember his second name - was going to say Watson but got a feeling that's a golfer!).

    The original picture was from a distance and looked a bit less noose like - but then being from a distance it's not enough to say it's not the same knot/noose.

    Maybe someone is just immature? When I was in Scouts someone fashioned a rope into a noose.
    But were your scouts in the southern states of the USA?

    It may have been immature but assuming the noose does have a different significance over there - which seems a reasonable assumption - it's still a racist act albeit one done out of immaturity rather than some strongly held racist views.
    It had been there for months and he didn't even see it. It was roundly condemned and not a single person came out to defend it (when they thought it was aimed at him). This whole thing is a joke. And BLM (as an organisation) is a joke too.
  • nickice
    nickice Posts: 2,439

    The whole "ah, but this symbol out of context doesn't mean the same thing as the symbol in context, so people who are offended by the symbol in context are stupid" argument is so weird.

    Why are you making that point?

    Because intent matters? I know you think it doesn't.
  • surrey_commuter
    surrey_commuter Posts: 18,867
    maybe they just don't like Bubba because of his personality?

    Is there a pattern of similar incidents with other Black Nascar drivers?

    maybe he could accept nascar is a hillbilly sport and switch to a more liberal, metropolitan form a motor racing with a more diverse drivership such as F!?
  • nickice
    nickice Posts: 2,439
    My son liked it when I did animal impressions. He used to like when I pretended to be a monkey. I remember him once getting me to do it in the supermarket and when I looked up there was a black cashier (who I doubt heard) quite nearby. Was that a racist incident?
  • DeVlaeminck
    DeVlaeminck Posts: 9,104
    nickice said:

    nickice said:

    In the UK I wouldn't really associate a noose with lynching but it'd be understandable if that is the association in the southern states of the USA.

    Let's be honest - if that's the case and the latest photo is genuine that has been done with racist intent even if it wasn't to target Bubba (I'm not on first name terms just can't remember his second name - was going to say Watson but got a feeling that's a golfer!).

    The original picture was from a distance and looked a bit less noose like - but then being from a distance it's not enough to say it's not the same knot/noose.

    Maybe someone is just immature? When I was in Scouts someone fashioned a rope into a noose.
    But were your scouts in the southern states of the USA?

    It may have been immature but assuming the noose does have a different significance over there - which seems a reasonable assumption - it's still a racist act albeit one done out of immaturity rather than some strongly held racist views.
    It had been there for months and he didn't even see it. It was roundly condemned and not a single person came out to defend it (when they thought it was aimed at him). This whole thing is a joke. And BLM (as an organisation) is a joke too.

    Well I can see why some kind of investigation would be warranted if you found a noose in a nascar garage - especially if that garage was assigned to the only black driver.

    I suppose the equivalent in the UK would be for Lewis Hamilton to be assigned a garage with BNP scrawled on the wall - those running F1 would want to find out who, why, when etc. If it turned out it had been there 9 months I might be asking why but I suppose a noose *may* be a little less obvious.

    Inevitably in the current climate the media picks the story up and perhaps it ends up a bigger issue than it deserves to be but then we are talking about it so it generates sales/clicks for them
    [Castle Donington Ladies FC - going up in '22]
  • Jeremy.89
    Jeremy.89 Posts: 457

    maybe they just don't like Bubba because of his personality?

    Is there a pattern of similar incidents with other Black Nascar drivers?

    maybe he could accept nascar is a hillbilly sport and switch to a more liberal, metropolitan form a motor racing with a more diverse drivership such as F!?

    What other black nascar drivers?

    The story is a bit bizzare. Man sees symbol with what are unquestionably racist connotations had it been left deliberately for him. Fellow drivers show support for him, which is quite a classy act. Investigation shows that the knot hadn't been left for him. Which is also good news, although obviously it's a fairly dubious symbol in the deep south.
  • surrey_commuter
    surrey_commuter Posts: 18,867
    Jeremy.89 said:

    maybe they just don't like Bubba because of his personality?

    Is there a pattern of similar incidents with other Black Nascar drivers?

    maybe he could accept nascar is a hillbilly sport and switch to a more liberal, metropolitan form a motor racing with a more diverse drivership such as F!?

    What other black nascar drivers?

    The story is a bit bizzare. Man sees symbol with what are unquestionably racist connotations had it been left deliberately for him. Fellow drivers show support for him, which is quite a classy act. Investigation shows that the knot hadn't been left for him. Which is also good news, although obviously it's a fairly dubious symbol in the deep south.
    the outcome of the white drivers showing solidarity has to be a plus point
  • DeVlaeminck
    DeVlaeminck Posts: 9,104
    Jeremy.89 said:

    maybe they just don't like Bubba because of his personality?

    Is there a pattern of similar incidents with other Black Nascar drivers?

    maybe he could accept nascar is a hillbilly sport and switch to a more liberal, metropolitan form a motor racing with a more diverse drivership such as F!?

    What other black nascar drivers?

    The story is a bit bizzare. Man sees symbol with what are unquestionably racist connotations had it been left deliberately for him. Fellow drivers show support for him, which is quite a classy act. Investigation shows that the knot hadn't been left for him. Which is also good news, although obviously it's a fairly dubious symbol in the deep south.
    Yeah you'd have to question the fan base any sport which is almost predominantly white these days...oh hang on...!




    ps - just a meaningless joke not meant to be taken seriously
    [Castle Donington Ladies FC - going up in '22]