First time build up from the frameset: Scott Team CR1
I'm presently planning to install ultegra R8000 and just got my hands on a full groupset. Still looking for a braze on front deraileur though, since that was out of stock (hmu if you need a 34.9 band-on 11spd or have a braze on available). I'm wondering if I can just put an older 10spd deraileur and use an old shifter for the front deraileur and brakes. Any experience with this?
Gonna get a 25mm laidback seatpost and long (120-140 mm) stem to better fit me. Still undecided on wheelset - any recommendations for a clydesdale?
As it stands now:
Comments
-
Don't think you can use a 10sp one but you can get standalone bands to which you can attach a braze on front mech.0
-
A front mech is a front mech - you can use any.
All the lever does is move it in two planes - out and in - its not as exact as a like a rear mech that has pull ratios etc.
You can also use Sora, Tiagra, 105 so lots of options.
MF would actually recommend not using an 8000 series front mech as tbey have a stupid design of a daft grub screw that takes up slack before you start setting up the mech - this grub screw is a pain in the back side and its all a faff.
He ran a 6700 front mech on his S3 for a whole with no problems so this route is recommended. Looks nice, don't have the stupid plastic cover to lose, easier to set up ......The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
0 -
I'm using a 10 speed front mech with 11 speed shifters and it works fine. Was going to get an 11 speed to match everything else but there is no need.0
-
Ah nice, thank you for all the responses0
-
Wheel wise, you could look at hand built ones. There are a number of wheel builders out there...
DCR Wheels
Ryanbuildswheels
Strada
thecycleclinic
JRA
etc etc.
https://google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=wheel+builders+uk&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8
There's probably one reasonably local to you.
Malcolm from thecycleclinic is on these forums too.
0 -
Avoid Hunt for wheels - overpriced and really not that good.
Good recommendations above - haven't heard anything bad about Malcolm's stuff tbh..The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
0 -
Surely you wouldnt put a band around a carbon frame?shirley_basso said:Don't think you can use a 10sp one but you can get standalone bands to which you can attach a braze on front mech.
Rule #5 // Harden The Feck Up.
Rule #9 // If you are out riding in bad weather, it means you are a badass. Period.
Rule #12 // The correct number of bikes to own is n+1.
Rule #42 // A bike race shall never be preceded with a swim and/or followed by a run.0 -
Yup - no problem at all.
Why not?.The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
0 -
Why not. My Boardman is band on.0
-
Exactly what SB said.
No problem with using them at all..The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
0 -
The current version's of the Shimano 11 speed mechanical FD, whether 105, Ultegra or Dura Ace shift up/down so much easier and smoother than previous versions, bearing in mind it's the cheapest component of the group it's madness not to get the correct part.0
-
Well, MF took off an 8000 one to use a last gen one and noticed absolutely no difference.
And apart from the fact the Ultegra ones at least don't look very nice, break easily, are heavier, have a stupid plastic cap that falls off and are a really, really stupid design to set up with a stupid cable pre load grub screw that chews up and are more expensive and you don't really need it as a different one works just as well without the shortcomings I suppose its an option.
#options.The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
0 -
#maybeMattFalle said:
Well, MF took off an 8000 one to use a last gen one and noticed absolutely no difference.
And apart from the fact the Ultegra ones at least don't look very nice, break easily, are heavier, have a stupid plastic cap that falls off and are a really, really stupid design to set up with a stupid cable pre load grub screw that chews up and are more expensive and you don't really need it as a different one works just as well without the shortcomings I suppose its an option.
#options
#maybeyouneedyourlbstodoyourspannering0 -
Nope - MFs spannering is fine. Its the LBS that fecked up the mech when trying to change a crank which they also fecked up.
Ultegra ain't that great no matter what the clubbies/marketing say, which is why its in a box in the loft and the Red that replaced it that MF fitted and fettled works perfectly.
#don'tbelievetheclubbiehype.The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
1 -
Oh - and 8000 left hand shifters also fall apart a lot which is why Madison have none left to do warranty swaps.
#Ultegra.Nothanks.GotanyCampyorSRAM?.The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
1 -
Yet you're recommending something that you no longer useMattFalle said:Nope - MFs spannering is fine. Its the LBS that fecked up the mech when trying to change a crank which they also fecked up.
Ultegra ain't that great no matter what the clubbies/marketing say, which is why its in a box in the loft and the Red that replaced it that MF fitted and fettled works perfectly.
#don'tbelievetheclubbiehype
#verystrange
Check the 5* reviews at Wiggle or Merlin and see what your missing.
Obviously clubbie hype.......
https://www.merlincycles.com/shimano-ultegra-fd-r8000-front-derailleur-11-speed-102883.html
https://www.wiggle.co.uk/shimano-ultegra-fd-r8000-front-derailleur-band-onilRagno said:
" tried the whole drivetrain, this is the diamond in groupset. It's like having an 800 pound gorilla move the chain into the big ring, just so close to effortless....makes my Dura Ace 9000 look pathetic. Highly recommended.Mr Foulds said:
I hate front derailleurs because I always have to spend too much time and frustration fiddling around with them to get them set up just right, this FD is however a true blessing and makes the process much easier!
0 -
Read the first post then read MF's reply - he didn't recommend using an 8000 mech.
If you must have it its only worth having because its cheap and you don't mind when you smash it up because its disposable. Its not even very nice to look at.
Tbh, you may as well fit a Tiagra front mech as its even cheaper and does exactly the same job.
And no, I'm not missing anything because I had it and took it off. Its not that great, but hey, if you're into second rate stuff then fill ya boots. I presume you have it, ya?.The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
0 -
Even the cranks are a bit hacking to tell the truth but until he tracks down something groovy in tbe stupid BB size he's stuck with them......
The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
0 -
Yes - 6700 not 8000 and its no longer there..
The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
0 -
Essentially the post was to say don't get hung up if you can't get an 8000 one as you aren't missing out on anything.
.The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
0 -
And that's where I (and the near 50 5* reviews on both Wiggle and Merlin) disagree with you, the new front mech system is a game changer, more complex to set up initially but once set up it works amazingly well.MattFalle said:Essentially the post was to say don't get hung up if you can't get an 8000 one as you aren't missing out on anything.
0 -
Its great until you try something better which it seems you haven't..
The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
0 -
105 gets 34 5* reviews.
The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
0 -
Bizarrely Dura Ace, Potenza, Chorus all get 5* reviews as well.
Surely not everyone can be right?
Surely not all of them are game changers?
Or are they all basically the same as its just, well, a frontmech?
THE PEOPLE NEED TO KNOW
In all seriousness though, Ultegra is great for a winter or training bike as you don't mind if you smash it up or forget to clean it for a few weeks. The hood and lever shapes make it cacky for anything serious though.
#gamechanger
#clubbiemarketing.The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
0 -
GRX also gets 5*s
Force gets 9 5*s at Wiggle.The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
0 -
MF, you can't just use any front derailleur with any shifter as you stated earlier. Your combo of 8000 shifters with a 6700 front derailleur isn't even recommended as compatible!
Your opinion of ultegra only being suitable for a winter bike is bonkers! How can it be great in winter but "cacky for anything serious"
#largepinchofsalt0 -
ultegra is shite compared to other options, its not the same as Dura Ace. MF is right thats just clubbie hype feeding on marketing bollox. Mind you most lycra wearing fuckwit clubbies round here believe anything. never met a bigger bunch of cntsflasher said:
Yet you're recommending something that you no longer useMattFalle said:Nope - MFs spannering is fine. Its the LBS that fecked up the mech when trying to change a crank which they also fecked up.
Ultegra ain't that great no matter what the clubbies/marketing say, which is why its in a box in the loft and the Red that replaced it that MF fitted and fettled works perfectly.
#don'tbelievetheclubbiehype
#verystrange
Check the 5* reviews at Wiggle or Merlin and see what your missing.
Obviously clubbie hype.......
https://www.merlincycles.com/shimano-ultegra-fd-r8000-front-derailleur-11-speed-102883.html
https://www.wiggle.co.uk/shimano-ultegra-fd-r8000-front-derailleur-band-onilRagno said:
" tried the whole drivetrain, this is the diamond in groupset. It's like having an 800 pound gorilla move the chain into the big ring, just so close to effortless....makes my Dura Ace 9000 look pathetic. Highly recommended.Mr Foulds said:
I hate front derailleurs because I always have to spend too much time and frustration fiddling around with them to get them set up just right, this FD is however a true blessing and makes the process much easier!0 -
Tis the season of goodwill.0
-
This.david37 said:
ultegra is shite compared to other options, its not the same as Dura Ace. MF is right thats just clubbie hype feeding on marketing bollox. Mind you most lycra wearing fuckwit clubbies round here believe anything. never met a bigger bunch of cntsflasher said:
Yet you're recommending something that you no longer useMattFalle said:Nope - MFs spannering is fine. Its the LBS that fecked up the mech when trying to change a crank which they also fecked up.
Ultegra ain't that great no matter what the clubbies/marketing say, which is why its in a box in the loft and the Red that replaced it that MF fitted and fettled works perfectly.
#don'tbelievetheclubbiehype
#verystrange
Check the 5* reviews at Wiggle or Merlin and see what your missing.
Obviously clubbie hype.......
https://www.merlincycles.com/shimano-ultegra-fd-r8000-front-derailleur-11-speed-102883.html
https://www.wiggle.co.uk/shimano-ultegra-fd-r8000-front-derailleur-band-onilRagno said:
" tried the whole drivetrain, this is the diamond in groupset. It's like having an 800 pound gorilla move the chain into the big ring, just so close to effortless....makes my Dura Ace 9000 look pathetic. Highly recommended.Mr Foulds said:
I hate front derailleurs because I always have to spend too much time and frustration fiddling around with them to get them set up just right, this FD is however a true blessing and makes the process much easier!
Chapeau.
.The camera down the willy isn't anything like as bad as it sounds.
0
