Do you bother with mudguards ?

bilabonic

Hi All

Finally purchased a Cube X disc model and it looks lovely in the flesh (crap on all pics).

Ii has mudguard mounts BUT it will obviously look awfull.

I know its only 'supposed' to be for winter months but not sure if i can bring myself to fit them.

Or is there a small/unobtrusive set out there ?

Cheers

daviesee

Ask the person behind you.
Or the person washing your jerseys/jackets.
A CX bike is a work horse to be used in foul conditions, not a prancing bling bike.

Short answer - Yes.

rubertoe

I run mudguards all year on my CX.

As said its a work horse.

markchalmers

The damage limitation to the bike is the most important slat and road dirt are not good for components.

mudcow007

markchalmers wrote:

The damage limitation to the bike is the most important slat and road dirt are not good for components.

+1

an a badger stripe up your 4rse off your back wheel isnt a good look

junglist_matty

Yet another fashion over function victim.... And you have a CX bike?!!?!?!?

wgwarburton

bilabonic wrote:

Hi All

Finally purchased a Cube X disc model and it looks lovely in the flesh (crap on all pics).

Ii has mudguard mounts BUT it will obviously look awfull.

I know its only 'supposed' to be for winter months but not sure if i can bring myself to fit them.

Or is there a small/unobtrusive set out there ?

Cheers

Yes, of course.

Mudguards should be standard on bikes-for-transport (ie commuting). If you're one of those wierdos that uses a carbon race-bike with a top-end groupset to get to work then maybe don't bother :-). For the rest of us... Yes.

Having said that: I live in Scotland- it rains a lot most of the year and they grit the roads heavily in winter. Keeping salty sand out of your drivetrain is a Good Idea.

I've experimented with riding mudguardless since about March (mostly 'cos I haven't had time to re-fettle the winter hack). The experiment has demonstarted clearly to me the folly of this approach for my purposes. I don't anticipate repeating it.

Cheers,
W.

Hoopdriver

Absolutely I use mudguards. Not only do they keep the mud off you, and anyone riding behind you, they keep salt and grit and mud out of your drivetrain.

UndercoverElephant

mudcow007 wrote:

an a badger stripe up your 4rse off your back wheel isnt a good look

I think badgers manage to carry it off with a certain debonair charm.

mudcow007

UndercoverElephant wrote:

mudcow007 wrote:

an a badger stripe up your 4rse off your back wheel isnt a good look

I think badgers manage to carry it off with a certain debonair charm.

ah-ha but they also have go faster stripes down their sides

they can pull the look off

cyclist with a brown sludge stripe on their derriere can not

iPete

I think Crud MK2 guards actually look pretty good, infact they are hard to notice at a glance.

Looking like you've sh*t yourself, not so cool.

BelgianBeerGeek

Another CX commuter here. With mudguards fitted. My commute is rural and with dairy farms en route. Hearing liquid cow sh*t splatter around the tyres and guards and knowing you're clean and dry is oddly satisfying.
I'm also quite lazy when it comes to bike cleaning so guards are another bonus.

bails87

Yet another CX commuter here, my CX is my only 'road' bike and I just leave the guards on year round. It's not as if it doesn't rain, or cows stop pooing on the lanes, in the summer.

notsoblue

I only have mudguards on bikes I ride in normal clothes.

cookeeemonster

I ride with mudguards all year round. don't notice them to be honest and I cant be asked checking the weather forecast before every ride to see if I should put them on/take them off to be honest.

And commuters without them are scum and shall be glared at in the rain as you pass the selfish mofos!!!

rick_chasey

People who commute without mudguards seriously f*ck me off.

Paul E

Raceblade xl's as I need to remove them to put my bike in a bag to store it at work, they do a good job for the coverage they give

memsley89

Rick Chasey wrote:

People who commute without mudguards seriously f*ck me off.

true dat...

cookdn

Yes, there is nothing worse than cycling in the rain and getting wetter from below than above. That's before you start considering water/salt damage to components and animals using the road as a toilet .

I've got black SKS Bluemels as recommended by Bails. A bit of a fiddle to fit, but solid and totally rattle free.

Best regards

gtvlusso

Mudguards don't fit on either frame; Both steel TT frames with very, very tight clearances and no mountings. I could put those seatpost mounted MTB things one, but they just look really silly and do nothing for anyone trailing in my wake.

Paul E

gtvlusso wrote:

Mudguards don't fit on either frame; Both steel TT frames with very, very tight clearances and no mountings. I could put those seatpost mounted MTB things one, but they just look really silly and do nothing for anyone trailing in my wake.

Raceblades would

rubertoe

Paul E wrote:

gtvlusso wrote:

Mudguards don't fit on either frame; Both steel TT frames with very, very tight clearances and no mountings. I could put those seatpost mounted MTB things one, but they just look really silly and do nothing for anyone trailing in my wake.

Raceblades would

I have raceblades on my cross as there are no mounts, they work a treat.

Kieran_Burns

Mudguards?

Hell No!

Why bother???

You just need to wash your clothes more often
Clean your bike more often
Replace your clothes more often
Replace parts on your bike more often
Get soaking wet feet every time it rains
You annoy everyone around you
Smell more

Mudguards? Nah.

gtvlusso

Paul E wrote:

gtvlusso wrote:

Mudguards don't fit on either frame; Both steel TT frames with very, very tight clearances and no mountings. I could put those seatpost mounted MTB things one, but they just look really silly and do nothing for anyone trailing in my wake.

Raceblades would

Nope - too tight for them. Get some tyre rub using 23mm tyres at the fork crown bridge and rear bridge.....And I ain't switching to tubs for commuting. Both are custom built frames from the 1970's/1980's.

pangolin

SKS Raceblades don't go under the bridge, you're thinking of Crud road guards

anonymousblackfg

I was doubtful about full SKS guards but my god they're a god send! am a complete convert even though I have horizontal drop outs and they make changing my rear wheel an unbelievable faff.

rebs

I don't use mudguards. I'm going to get wet and dirty anyway. Also means if you are getting sprayed on by my rear wheel in the wet.... YOU ARE TOO CLOSE TO ME!!!1111

I have boundry issues.... :P

notsoblue

Kieran_Burns wrote:

Mudguards?

Hell No!

Why bother???

You just need to wash your clothes more often
<snip>
Mudguards? Nah.

How often do you wash your cycling clothes?

Kieran_Burns

notsoblue wrote:

Kieran_Burns wrote:

Mudguards?

Hell No!

Why bother???

You just need to wash your clothes more often
<snip>
Mudguards? Nah.

How often do you wash your cycling clothes?

Generally when they start walking to the washing machine themselves...

tgotb

No mudguards on my CX bike until January when the CX season finishes, I just can't be bothered with taking them on and off every weekend.

If I need to ride it to work before then (and if it snows I will) I'll just have to put up with a wet a*se...

veronese68

daviesee wrote:

A CX bike is a work horse to be used in foul conditions, not a prancing bling bike.

This. A lot of cross bikes are just a hybrid with drops.



Runs and hides