Removing the Rear Casette

Hey everyone. I'm needing to buy the tool for removing the casette so I need to get the lockring socket in order to take the casette.
From what I can tell there is 2 different ones, some with a guide pin and some without. In your opinions, which is the better one to go for? Does it make much of a difference having the guide pin? I have seen a Chain Whip and casette lockring socket for £6 on good old Ebay!
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/SHIMANO-HG-FREEWHEEL-CASSETTE-REMOVER-TOOL-BIKE-9715A_W0QQitemZ150414957114QQcmdZViewItemQQptZUK_Spots_Leisure_Cycling_Tools_RepairKits?hash=item23056e1a3a
Thanks
From what I can tell there is 2 different ones, some with a guide pin and some without. In your opinions, which is the better one to go for? Does it make much of a difference having the guide pin? I have seen a Chain Whip and casette lockring socket for £6 on good old Ebay!
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/SHIMANO-HG-FREEWHEEL-CASSETTE-REMOVER-TOOL-BIKE-9715A_W0QQitemZ150414957114QQcmdZViewItemQQptZUK_Spots_Leisure_Cycling_Tools_RepairKits?hash=item23056e1a3a
Thanks
It's been a while...
0
Posts
I've been removing cassettes for years - and never used anything other than the tool shown on your Ebay link.
I'm assuming the one you've shown doesn't have a guide pin - in which case I'd suggest you really don't need one.
Take out the quick release skewer, wrap the chainwhip round one of the bigger cogs stick the cassette tool in and apply hard but controlled pressure and it should go with ease.
J
for me it comes down to what I find first.
Parktools :?:SheldonBrown
if the axle is solid or hollow a guide pin is worthless/unusable.
Parktools :?:SheldonBrown
is it a SS kit on a Cassette hub? same stuff as mentioned above.
Parktools :?:SheldonBrown
Its a 24/7 conversion kit which came on the wheel i got with my old the bike.