Scott Spark RC vs Specialized Epic 8 vs others

MetalRider
MetalRider Posts: 1
in MTB buying advice

Hello. I want to switch from hardtail to a full bike.

Which is better and why?

  • Scott Spark RC Team / Pro / Issue TR
  • Specialized Epic 8 Comp

Alternative options:

  • Orbea OIZ M-ProK
  • TM Scarp MT Elite AXS
  • Kross Earth TE
  • Lapierre XRM 6.9 (only XL 51cm available at store)
  • Mondraker F-Podium DC

Budget: maximum $6000 (assume 10% discount at store)

Purpose: XCM (Cross Country Marathon), both flat and mountains (stones, roots, etc)

Priorities:

  • which one has better geometry for racing?
  • which has better damper and fork? what are differences?
  • which has better (faster) wheels?
  • how about built-in components like dropper seatpost? are they good or need to be replaced?
  • does it make sense to buy cheaper (heavier) bike and replace wheels to some carbon ones?


Comments

  • MidlandsGrimpeur2
    MidlandsGrimpeur2 Posts: 2,115

    I can only comment on the Scott Spark, I have an older version that is equivalent to the Tesm Issue TR.

    It is a very stiff frame, perfectly capable for racing. It is a an XC bike but geometry and 120mm travel front and rear means it can handle more technical terrain.

    The Synchros alloy wheels that all mid range Scott's come with are good. I haven't felt the need to upgrade to carbon but that is personal choice.

    You will probably find that across all the choices you have listed, forks and components will be a similar level.

    The main thing with the Spark is the look, they have the hidden rear shock which gives the frame a very bulky downtube and bb area. I like it but not to everyone's taste.

Categories