Can't decide between three bicycles, which one should I buy?

flyingwolf

Hi guys,

I would like to buy an MTB bicycle but can't decide which one.

I will mostly use for some off-road drive for my own fun, some city roads and maybe some (amateur) competition time to time.

Here are three different bicycles, the only difference between the first two is the gear set is different and obviously gear count. I have read and heard that 1x12 is good inside the forest up to the hills but not for the speed on the road, is this true?

Questions:

*Which one you think would be better (in terms of long term quality and spare costs in case if it breaks in the future)

*Which bicycle would you buy?



1. https://www.orbea.com/de-de/fahrrader/m ... -h30-XT-19

2. https://www.orbea.com/de-de/fahrrader/m ... 0-eagle-19

3. https://www.ghost-bikes.com/en/bikes/ha ... ato-79-al/

robertpb

How much are you spending as there aren't any prices on the bikes you've put up.

Someone might suggest a better bike for a better price.

The parts that break are all common to other makes of bikes so you can discount that.

flyingwolf

robertpb wrote:

How much are you spending as there aren't any prices on the bikes you've put up.

Someone might suggest a better bike for a better price.

The parts that break are all common to other makes of bikes so you can discount that.

I am buying it from the contact of dealer. (I am not based in the UK but in the Europe)

First two bikes are 810 eur
And the last one is 695 eur

Just wanted to hear some experienced person opinion.

jamski

Between those, number 2.

flyingwolf

jamski wrote:

Between those, number 2.

Number or two?

jamski

flyingwolf wrote:

jamski wrote:

Between those, number 2.

Number or two?

This one

https://www.orbea.com/de-de/fahrrader/m ... 0-eagle-19