Fox Float X2 vs BOS Kirk
razorjack
Posts: 98
Hi.
I have Giant Reign 2016 w/ RS Monarch Plus R
and i want to upgrade my shock.
I have a choice of two shocks now (good deal on both): Fox Float X2 or BOS Kirk
Kirk will be tuned for my frame - there are 3 standard tunes, no need to tune Float X2.
which one will be better for aggressive rider ?
I have Giant Reign 2016 w/ RS Monarch Plus R
and i want to upgrade my shock.
I have a choice of two shocks now (good deal on both): Fox Float X2 or BOS Kirk
Kirk will be tuned for my frame - there are 3 standard tunes, no need to tune Float X2.
which one will be better for aggressive rider ?
0
Comments
-
-
wrong answer coil probably is very good indeed, but i prefer jumpy feel of an air. did you try any of these shocks ?0
-
Coils are better for everything, including jumping. Air shock don't respond as well to heavier landings and aren't as good when boosting bigger jumps. The Reign works really well with a coil.
Of those two, the Float X2 because of spares availability, better UK backup and more places to get it serviced.
There's nothing in it for performance so it's the things I those other things which would decide it for me.Transition Patrol - viewtopic.php?f=10017&t=130702350 -
razorjack wrote:wrong answer coil probably is very good indeed, but i prefer jumpy feel of an air. did you try any of these shocks ?
I wouldn't buy BOS as they lack any sort of customer service back up and I wouldn't buy the X2 cause its air and frankly too expensive.
I take it you've actually run a coil shock before then?0 -
i have a coil shock on my DH bike (Vivid), but didn't ride a coil on enduro bike,
i know these shocks are expensive but i can have them in about half of a retail price. (BOS - new, X2 - almost new)
(so cheaper than new DBCoilIL without a coil)
servicing - Fox - TFTuned, Mojo (close to Bristol - my place)
BOS - jungleproducts, madelkcycles (my friends from Dublin), but can they repair everything? or do they need to send a shock to france ?0 -
out of those two the X2 but it certainly wouldn't be my choice as a shock. I did look at the X2/DB AirCS but the coil is a much better way to go with better small bump sensitivity, better mid stroke support, no ramp up and a lot less to go wrong. The only reason to go air is if you are a weight wennie
Fox has the better service support in both spare parts/service and warranty. However, if you are big bloke you could have issues with the pressure cap they now have on the shock.0 -
i'm 73kg (about 80kg with a gear), and there is a stock Giant Reign (my bike) version with X2 performance, so i guess it's not a 'strange/uncommon' configuration.
https://www.giant-bicycles.com/de-de/bi ... ifications
with Monarch+R i need to put around 240psi (leverage ratio is quite high)0 -
you're going to have the same high pressure in the X2 as well due to the large negative air spring. Just somthing to consider.0
-
I see why you've been put off coil shocks if you've got a Vivvid! Certainly not one of the best coil shocks and a long way off the performance of a Cane Creek DB Coil.
Jungle can service BOS suspension when they can get parts (the reason why BOS get through so many distributors). They aren't the most reliable either.Transition Patrol - viewtopic.php?f=10017&t=130702350 -
it's not like i'm put off coil shocks, i think about these two, because i can have them cheaper than a new CC DBCoil IL without a spring! in any other case, i'd think and try coil (DBCoilIL or used CCDBcs)0