Time to retire my frame?

fleshtuxedo

My much loved Guerciotti badged dedacciai Scuro RS has a creak I think may be terminal, wanted to ask for some advice as I don't know what to do.

Frame has had 5 summers use, I'd guess 15k miles on it.

The creak is fairly loud, is apparent when I'm pushing hard and louder the harder I pedal. It's there seated or standing.

I've tried everything I can think of locate the noise - have swapped bb, cranks, pedals, wheels, headset bearings, bars, stem, seat mast.

There is no apparent damage to the frame anywhere. I've looked in particular inside the bb to see if the alloy sleeve for the cups is coming away from the carbon. There's no sign of any issues.

In fear of bringing down an entire chain gang, I'm not using it for now, but I need to decide what's next.

What does the forum suggest? I'd hate to scrap it, but how and where do I get it assessed? I don't see much point giving it to a bike shop....

keezx

A creak MAY come from the frame but the chance is pretty small.
Almost any attached part is more likely the cause.

napoleond

Doubt it's the frame. I thought I had a B creak once but it was wheel bearings.

ElectronShepherd

FleshTuxedo wrote:

ve swapped bb, cranks, pedals, wheels, headset bearings, bars, stem, seat mast.

You may have covered this under "pedals", but have you checked your shoes and cleats?

chrisaonabike

What happens if someone else rides it, maybe it's your knees?

fleshtuxedo

Thanks for the answers but as I said I've already swapped out everything suggested. The noise is not from shoes, I get it with trainers on.

What are the options/costs for getting the frame inspected?

jermas

Another possibility is the rear derailleur hanger creaking against the frame. Remove it, clean, then reassemble with a dab of grease (silicone grease is safest on carbon).

drlodge

If in doubt, strip everything down and I mean everything. Clean, inspect carefully and put back together again.

daniel_b

Have you checked the freehub\cassette?

My brother borrowed my turbo bike last summer to use for the road, and it made a horrible sound that we were convinced was BB or cranks, but tuther month when I removed the cassette, I saw the issue immediately.

ugo.santalucia

Sounds like a good excuse for a new bike, but it is almost certainly NOT the frame

imposter2.0

Front QR is usually the last thing I check...

fleshtuxedo

Daniel B wrote:

Have you checked the freehub\cassette?

My brother borrowed my turbo bike last summer to use for the road, and it made a horrible sound that we were convinced was BB or cranks, but tuther month when I removed the cassette, I saw the issue immediately.

I have tried 3 sets of wheels in the frame. No joy.

fleshtuxedo

Imposter wrote:

Front QR is usually the last thing I check...

That's the first thing I check!

fleshtuxedo

ugo.santalucia wrote:

Sounds like a good excuse for a new bike, but it is almost certainly NOT the frame

Like the optimism but I need to find something other than the frame that creaks or I'm stuffed

fleshtuxedo

jermas wrote:

Another possibility is the rear derailleur hanger creaking against the frame. Remove it, clean, then reassemble with a dab of grease (silicone grease is safest on carbon).

Now that's a good suggestion. Thanks, I'll try it.

Monty Dog

Not unknown for the alloy sleeves in BB shells to come unbonded

fleshtuxedo

Monty Dog wrote:

Not unknown for the alloy sleeves in BB shells to come unbonded

No, that's the fear.

Loctite drying out in the bolts for the mech hanger tonight, one of them was a tad loose. Fingers crossed....

andy_wrx

Mine creaks intermittently - it's younger than yours, only had 1 1/2 summers out of it

It was appalling in the Alps last year, I really hated grinding up long climbs on it creaking away, was so embarrassed I rode a lot of it on my own just so the rest of the group weren't listening to it as well, though nobody said anything : it ruined the trip.

Back on the flat, no creaking. Not had a peep out of it this year either, after its winter hibernation.

Sounds like it should be BB or crank, but pedals, saddle clamp, rear mech hanger, dunno - everything's been off, cleaned and greased an reassembled, no difference

fleshtuxedo

Jermas, thank you so much for the suggestion. I reloctited the hanger screws and the noise is gone.

Phew!

jermas

Great news! Thanks for the update.