Mud/splash proof shoes for flat pedals?

avalanche_expert

Do any of you chaps have any recommendations for shoes that will withstand muddy water being thrown up by the front wheel yet be compatible with flat pedals? It's becoming a bit tiring having freezing cold wet feet 20 mins into my rides now.

I've spent a fortune on cycling this year and it's never ending. The cheaper the better for me at the moment.

Also what would be best for my legs at this time of year? Leg warmers are just going to get wet and cold, any good MTB pants out there?

iwilldoit

Think you would be better off with waterproof socks, all shoes will let water in, my 5 10 low impact aren't bad and also my Shimano AM 45's are also OK, but if it's raining/puddles splashing up your leg it just runs down and into your shoes

cooldad

Sealskinz socks, preferably the snug merino lined ones.

FishFish

Or an added pair of socks and a supermarket poly bag between them keeps me happy. 10 p this winter though.

cooldad

Just means your feet get soaked in sweat instead of rain.

brianbee

[url=http://www.bikeradar.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=19742409#p19742409]Avalanche Expert[/url] wrote:

Do any of you chaps have any recommendations for shoes that will withstand muddy water being thrown up by the front wheel yet be compatible with flat pedals? It's becoming a bit tiring having freezing cold wet feet 20 mins into my rides now.

I've spent a fortune on cycling this year and it's never ending. The cheaper the better for me at the moment.

Also what would be best for my legs at this time of year? Leg warmers are just going to get wet and cold, any good MTB pants out there?

I use a pair of Karrimor muli-use shoes, 28 quid from sports direct, They are light comfortable, sturdy grippy and 100% water proof, provide the water isnt deeper than the shoes. If its complete wash out out, I wear my timberland walking sandals with water proof socks. That way the water can get out again and im not sloshing about in it

I wear a pair of tresspass snow boarding pants, They are quit excellent and seem indestructible ?,

paul.skibum

Yep snowboard pants and a pair of walking sandals with waterproof socks is definitely the way to go.

Although, if you are riding on anything remotely technical you may worry about grip on the pedals and perhaps overheating a little in those boarding pants.

I just dry my shoes after a ride and stick with my 5:10's - I have the freerider XVii which are reasonably waterproof across the top in any case and if you are riding a wet foot doesn't generally bother me. I got into the snow line yesterday and my feet got a little cold but that was more to do with standing in snow than being wet and cold. Leg wise I just wear a thin thermal under my shorts that covers my leg - keeps me warm enough in temps to around zero and also deals with the worst of leg run off so keeps my socks from getting soaked.

rockmonkeysc

I go for warmth rather than dry. Shimano AM41 shoes might not be waterproof (better than 5:10 though) but they keep your feet warm. A decent pair of lycra tights will also keep you comfortable.
It's a bit like wearing a wetsuit, it doesn't matter if you get a little bit wet as long as you stay warm. Whatever you wear the water will get in.
Walking boots and snowboard pants are awful for riding I'm, thats what I used to use until I found better kit.

ilovedirt

[url=http://www.bikeradar.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=19742981#p19742981]RockmonkeySC[/url] wrote:

I go for warmth rather than dry. Shimano AM41 shoes might not be waterproof (better than 5:10 though) but they keep your feet warm. A decent pair of lycra tights will also keep you comfortable.
It's a bit like wearing a wetsuit, it doesn't matter if you get a little bit wet as long as you stay warm. Whatever you wear the water will get in.
Walking boots and snowboard pants are awful for riding I'm, thats what I used to use until I found better kit.

What he said. Don't bother trying to keep yourself dry. With the best will in the world, you're going to get wet, there are no two ways about it.
Sealskinz socks with cycling tights over the top will keep your feet dry, even if your shoes aren't. You can get downhill pants, but they'll be way too hot for most riding, and not waterproof anyway. Waterproof trousers will make you overheat. Just make sure you have some decent warm kit and you'll be fine.

rockmonkeysc

Downhill pants aren't waterproof anyway.

brianbee

[url=http://www.bikeradar.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=19742971#p19742971]paul.skibum[/url] wrote:

Yep snowboard pants and a pair of walking sandals with waterproof socks is definitely the way to go.

Although, if you are riding on anything remotely technical you may worry about grip on the pedals and perhaps overheating a little in those boarding pants.

I just dry my shoes after a ride and stick with my 5:10's - I have the freerider XVii which are reasonably waterproof across the top in any case and if you are riding a wet foot doesn't generally bother me. I got into the snow line yesterday and my feet got a little cold but that was more to do with standing in snow than being wet and cold. Leg wise I just wear a thin thermal under my shorts that covers my leg - keeps me warm enough in temps to around zero and also deals with the worst of leg run off so keeps my socks from getting soaked.

They grip extremely well, they are timberland WALKING sandals designed to grip whilst allowing good ventilation and I seldom worry about over heating in November

jamski

I'm sure many won't agree, but I use £10 walking shoes from decathlon! They're light, grip well enough for me, and seem to withstand mud well enough. Can't say I've got them wet with rain but mud and puddles they seem good.

lostboysaint

Sealskinz socks are shite. Ridiculous sizing/shapes, awful feel. I stick with the tried and trusted Shimano AM45 (you'll want 41s for flat pedals) and DeFeet Woolie Boolie combination for that "mostly dry/very, very warm" feel during winter.

cooldad

Perhaps you have odd feet.

swod1

[url=http://www.bikeradar.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=19743079#p19743079]RockmonkeySC[/url] wrote:

Downhill pants aren't waterproof anyway.

bought some altura attack x trousers that are mtb specific and they are great in wet weather but cost a bit though, I bought them in a sale.

Back to the original question I use some am41s with some sealskinz socks and not a issue with wet feet only issue I get in wet weather is sliding about if I put my foot down as they don't have much grip in mud lol.

lostboysaint

[url=http://www.bikeradar.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=19743368#p19743368]cooldad[/url] wrote:

Perhaps you have odd feet.

Been discussed on here enough times (Sealskinz socks, not my feet!) to know that it's not them

FishFish

[url=http://www.bikeradar.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=19742753#p19742753]cooldad[/url] wrote:

Just means your feet get soaked in sweat instead of rain.

Maybe in the summer but not in the winter. Try it.

nasha48

lostboy - those woolie boolie socks I've just been looking at as want a pair or 2 of decent merino wools for this winter. Obviously you recommend them but do you happen to know the % merino wool in them? Also interested to know if the sizing is generous (I'm a canoe size 12)

The Rookie

[url=http://www.bikeradar.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=19743471#p19743471]FishFish[/url] wrote:

[url=http://www.bikeradar.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=19742753#p19742753]cooldad[/url] wrote:

Just means your feet get soaked in sweat instead of rain.

Maybe in the summer but not in the winter. Try it.

As I'm still cycling in T-shirt and shorts and I'm still getting sweaty, then yes in winter.

I use army Surplus MVP waterproof socks, do a great job, even though, like all waterproof socks, they feel a bit funny until you get used to them.

avalanche_expert

Thanks for all of your opinions guys it's a good help!

I think I'll be looking to get some waterproof socks to sort my feet out. Seems like a very easy solution!

My legs I'm not overly concerned about just yet as it's not been properly cold yet. I'm still going out in shorts, but I'm just thinking that once it's well down to the single figures and I'm splashing through cold water and mud I don't want to end up getting uncomfortable. I'm still covering decent distances, so comfort is paramount as its getting more grim out there.

I've seen some Castelli leg warmers which look like they will be worth trying. My top half is sorted, I've got good base layers and Gore wind proof cycling jackets, beanie hat and gloves. It's just my feet have been getting very wet and becoming cold as a result.

The socks seem like a sound idea!

ilovedirt

[url=http://www.bikeradar.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=19743396#p19743396]lostboysaint[/url] wrote:

[url=http://www.bikeradar.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=19743368#p19743368]cooldad[/url] wrote:

Perhaps you have odd feet.

Been discussed on here enough times (Sealskinz socks, not my feet!) to know that it's not them

Disagree, mine are great, with tights over the top at least.

Botty

another +1 for some cheap 'waterproof' shoes from decathlon

http://www.decathlon.co.uk/arpenaz-100-mens-waterproof-walking-shoes-yellow-id_8328437.html

JGTR

[url=http://www.bikeradar.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=19743360#p19743360]lostboysaint[/url] wrote:

Sealskinz socks are shite. Ridiculous sizing/shapes, awful feel. I stick with the tried and trusted Shimano AM45 (you'll want 41s for flat pedals) and DeFeet Woolie Boolie combination for that "mostly dry/very, very warm" feel during winter.

Strange......despite initial concerns I found them to be extremely comfortable, not sweaty and above all warm and waterproof. Means I can still use my summer shoes right through the year.

cooldad

Walking soles are the worst for riding in - all those ridges make it impossible to move your feet where and when you want to.

batmo

[url=http://www.bikeradar.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=19742773#p19742773]brianbee[/url] wrote:

I use a pair of Karrimor muli-use shoes, 28 quid from sports direct...

I often ride in a pair of Karrimor shoes that are quite old so the sole pattern is mostly gone. I keep buying things to replace them, but they're never as good so I go back. I use Sealskinz too, but I prefer the long ones and stick with shorts in the winter, with a pair of waterproof shorts (or cut down cheap waterproof trousers) for the wet rides.

HenryTheHoover

Anyone tried the Shimano AM7 yet that replaces the AM41 ? Would like to get a bit of feedback if poss. I am struggling to dry my AM41's out sufficiently between rides and the newer ones look like they have less padding.

loudog

just received a pair of five tens. they certainly look and feel mud/splash proof. I shall report back soon. probably with wet socks and disappointment as usual though

swod1

[url=http://www.bikeradar.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=19744143#p19744143]HenryTheHoover[/url] wrote:

Anyone tried the Shimano AM7 yet that replaces the AM41 ? Would like to get a bit of feedback if poss. I am struggling to dry my AM41's out sufficiently between rides and the newer ones look like they have less padding.

If mine get too wet I just stick them on top the radiator but dry the insides out a bit with a hair dryer which seem to do the job.

Otherwise wear some thicker socks to stop the insides getting wet?

wmorgs

Shimano AM 41's:
http://www.chainreactioncycles.com/shimano-am41-mtb-shoes-2015/rp-prod55371
And
Sealskinz Socks:
http://www.chainreactioncycles.com/sealskinz-mid-weight-knee-length-sock/rp-prod109154

_HENDO_

FIve Ten Impacts.
Give them a quick wipe and they're ready to go again. Much easier to dry than the bulky old ones too.

nasha48

Altura Attack overshoes - perfect for flats, easy on/off, best £28 I've spent in a long while