Assos Climashutz verus Castelli Tempesta

piersj01

Does anyone have any experience of these waterproof jackets? I'm want to buy a good durable waterproof and am not sure which one to go for. I realise expecting good breathability in a fully waterproof jacket is unrealistic but am more interested in which has the best waterproof and windproof characteristics to keep you warm and dry over a winter jacket this winter.

Thanks