Need some help choosing a MTB setup

DownTheHillIGo

Hello,

I am very new to the MTB world and I would need some help deciding between 2 bikes. I would like to know which one has the best parts. The frame will not be held into consideration. Just the parts.

First one:


The second one:
Fork: Manitou Minute Pro m. MILO, Federweg 100 mm
Crankset: Shimano SLX 42/32/24 Z
Shifter: Shimano XT
Hub: Shimano M525
Wheels: Alex DP17
Tire: Michelin Wild Grip'R 26x2.1
Brakes: Hayes Stroker Trail Disc Brake, 180/160mm
Handlebar and stem: FSA Riser XC-282L, FSA OS-190
Seat: Selle Italia Q-Bik XC Flow, FSA SL-280

This is all I have in terms of specs. Not considering the frame, if both had the same price which one would you choose.

Thank you.

Chunkers1980

Image missing

DownTheHillIGo

Sorry about that.

First bike setup:
Front derailleur:Shimano Deore FD-M610, for 40/42T, dual pull
Rear Derailleur:Shimano Deore, RD-M610, 10 speed, direct mount
Shifter levers:Shimano Deore SL-M610, optical gear display
Chainwheel:Shimano Deore FC-M612-L, 40-30-22T, 175mm
Bottom Bracket:Shimano
Sprocket Casette:Shimano CS-HG62-10, 10-speed 11-13-15-17-19-21-24-28-32-36T
Chain:KMC X-10, 114 Links & Missing Link
Brake type:Shimano BR-M446, rotor front - 180mm / rear - 160mm
Brake levers:Shimano BL-M445
Frame:Alloy 6061
Front suspension:Rock Shox XC30 TK 27,5 Solo Air, travel 120mm
Head set:semi-integrated
Handlebar:Truvativ STYLO T10, φ31,8mm, L:680mm, Rise:20°
Stem:Truvativ STYLO T20
Seat post:Truvativ STYLO T20, φ31,6mm, Length:350mm
Saddle:WTB Volt Sport
Pedals:HTI A70 Alu pedal - With Reflector K - mark
Front Hub:Shimano HB-M475-L, 32H, Quick Release
Rear Hub:Shimano FH-M475-L, 32H, Quick Release
Rims:BlackLine 27,5" Disc
Tires:Wolverine SS 2.0 Comp, Normal Rubber 27tpi Casing, Wire Steel Bead, 650gr

Chunkers1980

There's info missing from the second one so can't compare.

DownTheHillIGo

I know but that's all I have. I would appreciate an opinion on the parts that are in both specs. Like the front suspension, brakes and so on.

The Rookie

Of the parts listed, just about every one is better on the second bike is better.

rockmonkeysc

Just about everything is better on the second.
Why don't you want to reveal what the frame is? That will have a major impact on how the bike rides and if it's used, the parts may not be suitable for the frame.