Left shifter always breaks?

Bwgan
Bwgan Posts: 389
edited April 2013 in Road general
Been looking on ebay for a set of shifters and there is loads of single right side for sale, does that mean that the left ones break more?

Comments

  • keef66
    keef66 Posts: 13,123
    Shimano had a bunch of LH shifter failures a few years ago. Was at the time when the LH shifter could be used for double or triple, and the failures seemed to be when used for a double. (My triple from that era is still fine)
  • domc21
    domc21 Posts: 86
    my triple failed round a 60 mile sportive..... it was a tough 25 miles back stuck in the top ring!!!!!
  • careful
    careful Posts: 720
    My 105 5700 L triple shifter broke in normal use as a triple. This is more recent than the batch mentioned above. It seems that they are all suspect.
  • keef66
    keef66 Posts: 13,123
    domc21 wrote:
    my triple failed round a 60 mile sportive..... it was a tough 25 miles back stuck in the top ring!!!!!

    Could you not have undone the cable clamp at the mech and dropped it on to the granny ring?
  • Lazybike
    Lazybike Posts: 22
    Broke my 5600 left shifter on Sunday....going to try the 5601 double specific one.
  • andi1363
    andi1363 Posts: 350
    Not so much break as wear out. I am on my 4th ultgra STI in 2 years.
  • racingcondor
    racingcondor Posts: 1,434
    5600 was a problem batch partly because it was designed as both double and triple (Ultegra came in two versions, 105 had one, presumably to cut machining costs a little). I imagine 5601 (double only) came out 1-2 years after the original version to fix the problem.

    That said, every manufacturer I've heard of has been very good indeed at providing quick replacements for free if a problem batch/design is identified.
  • rolf_f
    rolf_f Posts: 16,015
    andi1363 wrote:
    Not so much break as wear out. I am on my 4th ultgra STI in 2 years.

    How many miles do you get out of them?
    Faster than a tent.......
  • plowmar
    plowmar Posts: 1,032
    Six years on my triple and three years? on a double, so perhaps the oldies are the best.
  • forgotrafe
    forgotrafe Posts: 637
    I have a brand new Ultegra 6700 left double shifter for sale if anyone is interested.

    Bought because I didn't think Shimano was going to replace my broken one under warranty but they did. Sadly not before I panic bought one because I've an event I don't want to miss.

    Almost impossible to find singularly.