New Computer: Polar CS500 or Garmin Edge 500?

Mefster

My Polar S625X watch appears to have finally died. Intermittent HR and speed- todays ride started with a speed of 124km/h and a HR of 240 before it packed up: I'm guessing that was a little inaccurate!

I don't do as much running now so want to get a new bike computer. The features I would like are:
1.Speed
2. Cadence
3. Heart Rate
4. Altitude/Total Ascent
5. The ability to use on a turbo trainer

I also like the ability to download data to software to software so I can record and monitor training, and the option of fitting to a second bike.

I'm not overly bothered with mapping- the few times this has been needed I usually have an iPhone with me. Not too concerned with power meter compatibility- I can see I'll ever be in the market for this at current prices.

The Polar CS500 and Garmin Edge 500 seem to be the 2 best options. I'm aware that lots of comparisons err towards the Edge, but often this is related to mapping or power- both of which are not key issues for me.

The Polar sensors do not have replacable batteries, but from my experience they seem to last a long time.

Does anyone who owns either of these computers and have any advice?

Thanks in advance!

Mefster

After reading the recent bad review of Garmin customer service, along with higher cost (especially to get HR and cadence) I'm swinging towards the Polar CS500, especially as I can use it on a turbo trainer.

Any final input before I purchase?

Cheers!

Calpol

I have the Garmin. I think its one the best cycling related purchase I have made. It does everything I need it to do and more. Uploading data is a cinch and whether you use Strava or Garmin Connect to analyse your data is up to you. I use Strava. I wouldnt be too put off by the odd post on here regarding Garmin customer service. They sell bucket loads of these things and occasionally you will get the odd problem. I bet 99% of people have no issues and don't post it on a forum. I don't see too many of the pro peloton using Polar and I don't know too much about them. Does the Polar have GPS?