MTB-your recommendation: Commencal HD4 "vs" Scott Aspect40

jackextender

COMMENCAL specs:

Frame Premier Disc 6061 T6 (updated)
Fork RST Blaze ML lock-out 80mm on XS, 100mm on S & M, 120mm on L & XL
Headset Neco 1”1/8 ball retainer
Stem COMMENCAL Premier OS
Bar COMMENCAL Premier 1” OS 6061
Grips COMMENCAL Kraton black
Brakes Tektro Draco hydraulic 160/160 on all except 180/160 on L & XL
Shifters Shimano Acera 3x8
Front Mech Shimano Acera
Rear Mech Shimano Acera
Bottom Bracket FSA Square sealed bearings
Cranks Suntour XCT
Chain KMC 8 speed
Cassette Sram PG820 8s 11-32
Rims Jalco double wall
Hubs COMMENCAL disc brakes
Spokes Stainless 64p 3x lacing black
Tires Maxxis Crossmark 26x2.10/Geax Suguaro 26x2.2
Seatpost COMMENCAL Premier no offset
Saddle COMMENCAL by Velo
Color Cyan Blue, Matt Black
Weight 14,2kg

*************************************

SCOTT specs:

Frame: Aspect Alloy 6061, performance geometry, integrated headtube
Fork: Suntour XCM-H with lockout, 100mm travelFront
Derailleur: Shimano M190Rear
Derailleur: Shimano Acera
Number of Gears: 24Shifters:Shimano EF51L EZ-Fire Plus
Chainset: Shimano M171
Chainrings: 42/34/24 tooth
Bottom Bracket: Shimano UN26, cartridge type
Cassette: Shimano HG31 11-32 tooth 8-speed
Chain: KMC Z7
Pedals: Wellgo C127SFront
Brake: Shimano M375L Mechanical disc
Rear Brake: Shimano M375L Mechanical disc
Brake Levers: Shimano Integrated
Handlebars: Scott Aspect OS, 15mm rise, 8 degree backsweep, 640mm
Stem: Scott TDS-D345A-8
Headset: Ritchey Logic OE Integrated
Rims: Araya TX-633, D-Wall, Black
Front Hub: Scott Disc Team CLRear
Hub: Shimano RM35 CLSpokes:14 G stainless black
Front Tyre: Schwalbe Black Jack, 26x2.1
Rear Tyre:
Schwalbe Black Jack, 26x2.1
Saddle: Scott Aspect
Seatpost: Scott, 31.6mm
Weight: 14.30 kg / 31.50 lbs

cooldad

Budget? But I suspect you could do better.

jackextender

Each bike is around: 525 USD / 425 Euros; thats also the money that i expect to spend for a new MTB, Thanks for your kind help!

cooldad

Where are you, the US? - most people here are in the UK, so hard to comment as prices differ so much.

jackextender

Yes, California, and the Commencal is a special offer, no many dealers here offer european brands, i understand tht Commencal is from Andorra and Scott is a swiss brand now, the question is if somebody haze a idea about the specifications and can give me a recomendation! Thanks

supersonic

Very little in it, the Soctt has a marginally better fork.