Is My Frame Knackered?

ETizzle

Hi,

I have just bought a Planet X frame (second hand)
When it arrived I noticed it had a crack on the top tube.
I know that any cracks on a carbon frame is bad news, but I wasn't sure if it was just in the paint work.
To me it looks like something heavy has fallen on it, and I was thinking about sending back and getting a refund.
The pictures don't really show how bad it is to be honest, it looks worse in real life





Any information would be very useful
Thanks

Giraffoto

If the seller didn't tell you it had a crack in the top tube (or even a scuff in the paint, if that's all there is) then you should have a case for asking for a refund.

ETizzle

Yeah I think im gonna ask for a refund, I don't trust that crack.
Tanks

rothers_bikeo

Send it back, that's had a serious whack.

andy46

I wouldn't be happy with that, I don't think I'd trust it.

Hope you get a refund.

ETizzle

I got a refund.
Seller still didnt think there was anything wrong with it :?

Thanks for you help

keef66

It was a hideous colour too. I think you're well rid of it.