Ultegra expensive or Red Cheap?

Sgt_Pepper
Sgt_Pepper Posts: 172
edited April 2012 in Road buying advice
I'm looking into buying a Dolan Ares, So I've had a mess round with the price guide and options on their site.

I really wanted to go the Ultegra route, Full bike =£2372

I also priced up Sram out of curiosity and it only comes in at Red £2419 Force at £2219

I always thought ultegra was supposed to be competing with Force, why is it so close in price to Red

I dont really want Sram but at only £47 more i'm having a dillema. Shimano's second Groupset or Srams Top?

what would the good people of BR do.

I'm currently using 105, how hard is it to adapt to Sram.

Comments

  • There is a new sram red out which is far more expensive.This might have some thing to do with it?
  • indysmith
    indysmith Posts: 276
    Sgt_Pepper wrote:

    I dont really want Sram but at only £47 more i'm having a dillema. Shimano's second Groupset or Srams Top?

    Well there's your answer!
    Both groups perform a lot better than 95% of people do on their bikes; if you've got the cash to splash then buy the one that you prefer. It's all personal preference.
  • nochekmate
    nochekmate Posts: 3,460
    All personal preference of course but for me I'd take Force over Ultegra never mind Red. Got both Red & Force on my bikes
  • mroli
    mroli Posts: 3,622
    To answer the question about how easy it is to switch to sram from shimano, I had a variety of shimano groupset (sora, tiagra, 105) before switching. Probably took me about 10 miles to get comfortable with the double tap system. It is very easy to use.
  • indysmith
    indysmith Posts: 276
    mroli wrote:
    To answer the question about how easy it is to switch to sram from shimano, I had a variety of shimano groupset (sora, tiagra, 105) before switching. Probably took me about 10 miles to get comfortable with the double tap system. It is very easy to use.
    I also made the switch from Shimano to SRAM, and took to it pretty much instantly - it's an extremely intuitive and natural system. The only thing that may or may not appeal is that SRAM shifts are a lot noisier, and provide a lot more positive feedback, i.e. you know when you've shifted on a SRAM system, whereas Shimano is extremely smooth and very efficient.
    A major (to me, at least) advantage of SRAM is that the brake levers themselves are fixed and can't be pushed to the side like Shimano, which feels flimsier whilst braking.
  • giant_man
    giant_man Posts: 6,878
    i wouldn't recommend that Sram rubbish to anyone quite honestly. Out of the two, ultegra is a far superior groupset.
  • napoleond
    napoleond Posts: 5,992
    I've been running Sram Red the last 4 years, it's great! I find the hoods more comfortable than Shimano (I have had Ultegra too on a winter bike). Despite the extra weight the Ultegra Crank is IMO better than the Sram Red however...
    Insta: ATEnduranceCoaching
    ABCC Cycling Coach
  • rozzer32
    rozzer32 Posts: 3,922
    giant man wrote:
    i wouldn't recommend that Sram rubbish to anyone quite honestly. Out of the two, ultegra is a far superior groupset.

    I wouldn't recommend that fishing tackle (shimano) rubbish to anyone quite honestly. Out of the two, Force is a far superior groupset (lighter, cheaper and better shift system).


    But that is my personal opinion. Obviously mine and yours differ :wink:
    ***** Pro Tour Pundit Champion 2020, 2018, 2017 & 2011 *****
  • giant_man
    giant_man Posts: 6,878
    good grief, nap d, you're so cheap mate :wink:
  • sungod
    sungod Posts: 17,192
    ignoring the groupset bigotry, the reality is that all modern groupsets are ok, some are are smidge lighter, or more aero, or whatever, but they all work well if correctly installed and adjusted

    the biggest practical difference is in the hoods and the shifting method

    if you prefer shimano's hood shape and shifting, get the ultegra

    if you prefer sram's hood shape and shifting, get the red

    fwiw i've got one bike with mixed shimano, one with red, i prefer the red double-tap shifting, but both are ok
    my bike - faster than god's and twice as shiny
  • doubledenim
    doubledenim Posts: 119
    indysmith wrote:
    mroli wrote:
    To answer the question about how easy it is to switch to sram from shimano, I had a variety of shimano groupset (sora, tiagra, 105) before switching. Probably took me about 10 miles to get comfortable with the double tap system. It is very easy to use.
    I also made the switch from Shimano to SRAM, and took to it pretty much instantly - it's an extremely intuitive and natural system. The only thing that may or may not appeal is that SRAM shifts are a lot noisier, and provide a lot more positive feedback, i.e. you know when you've shifted on a SRAM system, whereas Shimano is extremely smooth and very efficient.
    A major (to me, at least) advantage of SRAM is that the brake levers themselves are fixed and can't be pushed to the side like Shimano, which feels flimsier whilst braking.


    I don't agree with you there I am afraid. Ultegra and down the Shimano groupset yes the shifting is less solid and smooth but Dura-ace is very loud and shifts with real purpose. This is true for both mechanical and electronic versions. Remember any di2 shifters are fixed, you don't move the brake lever.

    Mind you, I run ultegra on my winter bike and given the choice between Red and Ultegra with the bike in question I'd go with Red. In my opinion it's more in a league for dura-ace