Silly question
paulus69
Posts: 160
Its a bit quiet in here and I have a question that I am sure will provoke some discussion, whats teh big hoohaa about single speed bikes?
Theres not a huge weight saving getting rid of a few cogs
Its either going to be really hard going uphill or max out on the flat/downhill
Deraillors work quite well (or at least in my experience they do)
So whats the bonus of a single speed?
Theres not a huge weight saving getting rid of a few cogs
Its either going to be really hard going uphill or max out on the flat/downhill
Deraillors work quite well (or at least in my experience they do)
So whats the bonus of a single speed?
0
Comments
-
less bits to maintain. so less likely to break.Hat + Beard0
-
Bit lighter, less maintenance, stops you being lazy. Don't find I really need gears on a flat 6 mile commute.
It's also more enjoyable (if you find SS more enjoyable, which people that find SS more enjoyable do)
But there are plenty of threads that'll rehash the arguments
Jesus rode fixed btw.0 -
They are "cool".
I like mine as its nippy and easier to negotiate traffic than my road bike.0 -
0
-
Less to maintain, no mucky dérailleur to get your skinny jeans dirty. Also no shifters or brakes to spoil the clean line of your handlebars. I'd go singlespeed, but I don't like lumberjack shirts, and can't grow a moustache0
-
Personally, I need gears to get me up hills and I need a freewheel so I can get my legs back on the way down, but at a guess I'd think that single speed will give cyclists a greater feeling of terrain so that instead of keeping up a cadence to minimise the effect of an incline, the SSer has to respond more closely, grinding or spinning according to the physical challenge of contours.0
-
It's fun and challenging in a different way to ride a bike with only one gear. Less to think about, nothing to use but your legs. I don't ride fixed, but I do have a single speed, and I love it, for those reasons more than the maintenance (I don't ride it in the winter anyway)
http://www.velochocolate.co.uk Special Treats for Lifestyle Cyclists
From FCN from 8 (road bike, beard, bag, work clothes) to 15 (on my Brompton)0 -
0
-
Doesn't need cleaning every couple of weeks in winter
and
I can track stand it - going stop start across town - that counts for a lot.
and
Chicks dig it
and
I'm nails and have a ring the size of a Vinyl Album.Fixed gear for wet weather / hairy roadie for posing in the sun.
What would Thora Hurd do?0 -
Alphabet wrote:
And sensibly doesn't seem to mention the myth of reduced maintenance costs and time. This might apply to a comparison of a modern shifter system with single speed but, old school shifter systems (with maybe 7 or less speeds on the cassette) really need no more maintenance and are probably cheaper to run than single speeds what with the parts costing little and rarely needing replacement. A five speed (single chainring) down tube shifted bike is probably the ultimate balance between function and low maintenance.
You'd have to live out East or on Kirkstall road to run a single speed in Leeds and not be certifiable - quite a few must........Faster than a tent.......0 -
0
-
Rolf F wrote:Alphabet wrote:
And sensibly doesn't seem to mention the myth of reduced maintenance costs and time. This might apply to a comparison of a modern shifter system with single speed but, old school shifter systems (with maybe 7 or less speeds on the cassette) really need no more maintenance and are probably cheaper to run than single speeds what with the parts costing little and rarely needing replacement. A five speed (single chainring) down tube shifted bike is probably the ultimate balance between function and low maintenance.
You'd have to live out East or on Kirkstall road to run a single speed in Leeds and not be certifiable - quite a few must........
yeah, massively depends on your route. in london they utterly make sense because it's not really hilly at all in central and 90% of my journey is flat as a pancake. Not so good for cumbria I'd imagine...0 -
Rolf F wrote:Alphabet wrote:
And sensibly doesn't seem to mention the myth of reduced maintenance costs and time. This might apply to a comparison of a modern shifter system with single speed .
There's no ''might' about it.- 2023 Vielo V+1
- 2022 Canyon Aeroad CFR
- 2020 Canyon Ultimate CF SLX
- Strava
- On the Strand
- Crown Stables
0 -
Rolf F wrote:Alphabet wrote:
And sensibly doesn't seem to mention the myth of reduced maintenance costs and time. This might apply to a comparison of a modern shifter system with single speed but, old school shifter systems (with maybe 7 or less speeds on the cassette) really need no more maintenance and are probably cheaper to run than single speeds what with the parts costing little and rarely needing replacement. A five speed (single chainring) down tube shifted bike is probably the ultimate balance between function and low maintenance.
You'd have to live out East or on Kirkstall road to run a single speed in Leeds and not be certifiable - quite a few must........
Unless of course you are amongst the enlightened and run a fixed gear with a belt.....maintenance is as close to zero as it is possible to get. My belt tension hasn't drifted noticeably in a thousand miles, and, er, that leaves tyre pressures and one brake caliper.
I cleaned my bike yesterday after a particlualrly filthy ride on canal paths and through parks. Took me sub two minutes with a wet rag - sparkling even under the BB. Betcha jealous now!FCN 5 belt driven fixie for city bits
CAADX 105 beastie for bumpy bits
Litespeed L3 for Strava bits
Smoke me a kipper, I'll be back for breakfast.0 -
SimonAH wrote:Rolf F wrote:Alphabet wrote:
And sensibly doesn't seem to mention the myth of reduced maintenance costs and time. This might apply to a comparison of a modern shifter system with single speed but, old school shifter systems (with maybe 7 or less speeds on the cassette) really need no more maintenance and are probably cheaper to run than single speeds what with the parts costing little and rarely needing replacement. A five speed (single chainring) down tube shifted bike is probably the ultimate balance between function and low maintenance.
You'd have to live out East or on Kirkstall road to run a single speed in Leeds and not be certifiable - quite a few must........
Unless of course you are amongst the enlightened and run a fixed gear with a belt.....maintenance is as close to zero as it is possible to get. My belt tension hasn't drifted noticeably in a thousand miles, and, er, that leaves tyre pressures and one brake caliper.
I cleaned my bike yesterday after a particlualrly filthy ride on canal paths and through parks. Took me sub two minutes with a wet rag - sparkling even under the BB. Betcha jealous now!
Depends, how about an Alfine with a belt drive?Mud - Genesis Vapour CCX
Race - Fuji Norcom Straight
Sun - Cervelo R3
Winter / Commute - Dolan ADX0 -
In essence:
For both SS and fixed:
Light bike
virtually no maint
quick to maintain if you have to do anything
great eexercise - same gear everywhere in every situation
for fixed:
constantly pedalling
Love it! Great for my (approx) 20 mile a day commute.
Have this same argument with some of the guys in the office. They swear that you can only ride a bike with gears......however, I am the highest miler in the office and beg to differ.0