12-27 to a 11-28 10speed

Brocade
Brocade Posts: 433
edited July 2009 in Workshop
Folks,
I have a 12-27 10-speed cassette. Gear's don't make enough difference and I want something easier... can I switch out a 12-27 to a 11-28 10-speed using the same chain and derailleurs ?
Thanks
BMC Pro Machine
Enigma Ego

Comments

  • Wamas
    Wamas Posts: 256
    It depends what derailleur you have. One extra tooth may not make that much of a difference, worth checking how much adjustment there is with your derailler first.

    You may need to extend your chain buy a pair of links, but you may just get away with it.
    Put your chain on the largest chain ring and the largest cassette ring and see whether there is any play left in your deraiiler, if it stretched out as far as it will go, you would either need to add a couple of links (or buy a new chain), or just avoid using the largest chainring and largest cassette ring until you need a new chain - which is always good practice anyway.

    One extra tooth at the back won't make that much of a difference though, what chainset are you running, changing to a compact or triple would make much more of a difference.
  • John.T
    John.T Posts: 3,698
    27 teeth is officially the largest you can use with Shimano road mechs (unless you have Dura-ace 7900) but with carefull chain length and B screw adjustment it will work. As Wamas says one tooth will not make much difference. You should consider a compact chainset. If you already have one the next cheapest option is a custom cassette and an MTB mech.
  • Brocade
    Brocade Posts: 433
    Many thanks. Would a compact work with a 11-28 ?
    BMC Pro Machine
    Enigma Ego
  • pete600
    pete600 Posts: 142
    I did the same went from a 11-27 to 11-28 to be honest it didn't make any difference. FSA compact crank, Dura ace 7800 derailleur Sram cassette. The only up side was the Sram cassette was a lot lighter than the shimano cassette i replaced.
    I did not need to make any adjustments just swapped the cassettes and it worked fine



    http://photos-c.ak.fbcdn.net/photos-ak-snc1/v2705/141/117/733412044/n733412044_2092714_2808354.jpg
  • Brocade
    Brocade Posts: 433
    Thanks.
    BMC Pro Machine
    Enigma Ego
  • wiffachip
    wiffachip Posts: 861
    John.T wrote:
    27 teeth is officially the largest you can use with Shimano road mechs

    is that correct ? my SCR1 came with 105 mechs and 28 (SRAM). Does that exceed the recommended max ?
  • John.T
    John.T Posts: 3,698
    wiffachip. Yes but Shimano are very conservative with their specs and many are using 28 with no trouble.