New steel frame

busterman
busterman Posts: 88
edited July 2007 in MTB buying advice
I’ve decided I want to buy a new bike. I don’t particularly need one, but I’ve decided to treat myself to something special for absolute best, i.e. not the Bryan Chapman on a wet weekend.

My current steed is a steel Bob Jackson, which I enjoy riding a great deal. I had though about getting something more sporty in carbon, but have decided to stick to steel for a few reasons:

1. I really like the retro look of steel bikes. The 953 steel can be left unpainted, for a super-chic bare steel look.
2. I tend to ride only audaxes, and hilly audaxes at that. I like to ride fast, but comfort is also a key factor.
3. I’m 6’2” and have long legs even for a chap of my size. A custom steel frame is going to be a lot easier on my back, legs and arms.
4. The new Reynolds 953 steel results in a frame that’s only 700g heavier than a carbon model. That’s nothing compared to the crap I carry round on a ride anyway.

So, with this in mind, I’ve been looking for framemakers who can work with 953 steel. So far I’ve found Bob Jackson, Mercian, Brian Rourke and Dae Yates. I really like my Bob Jackson but I’ve heard of other people who have been less than happy with what they got. I’m not sure I’m ready to trust them with £1300 for a frame made out of such a tricky material to work with. I’m gravitating towards Mercian, but only on account of their reputation.

Could I ask what experiences any of you have of these companies, or indeed 953 steel? Any feedback gratefully received.