Shimano Alivo 9spd shifters with SRAM rear mech and cassette?

kwsmithphoto
kwsmithphoto Posts: 4
edited November 2017 in MTB workshop & tech
Hello. I'm new here but I spent some time searching and couldn't find the answer I'm looking for.

I bought an older bike with an SRAM drivetrain and trigger shifters, but one of the shifters was a basically shot so I bought some n.o.s. Alivo triggers shifters since I liked the design better, and assumed they would work. They don't. The Shimano shifters don't have enough travel to move the chain all the was across the cassette now. It isn't a chainline or derailleur stop point problem, it's definitely a mismatch somewhere.

Question: Can I swap out the cassette for a Shimano part, do I need a Shimano derailleur, or both?

Thanks. I hope someone can help!

Comments

  • cooldad
    cooldad Posts: 32,599
    You need to match the shifters and mech, so Sram with Sram or Shimano with Shimano. Cassette doesn't matter, the spacing is the same, the pull ratio of the mech and shifters isn't.

    (Sram named shifters - eg. Rocket work with Shimano mechs, but not Sram mechs. The numbered Sram shifters only work with Sram mechs)

    Front shifters are interchangeble.
    I don't do smileys.

    There is no secret ingredient - Kung Fu Panda

    London Calling on Facebook

    Parktools
  • kwsmithphoto
    kwsmithphoto Posts: 4
    Thanks for the quick answer! I had a feeling that was the problem but sadly, it means I gotta buy a Shimano rear mech...

    Thanks again. --Kevin
  • mattyfez
    mattyfez Posts: 638
    Or a sram shifter will be a bit cheaper, but if you want the shimano shifters, then yes.
  • kwsmithphoto
    kwsmithphoto Posts: 4
    That was my first idea, before I bought the Shimano shifters, but the quickest shop to me didn't have any 3/9spd SRAM triggers. So I bought the Shimano's, installed them and their new cable, cut the cable (so I couldn't return then), then realized I had a problem. Oops!

    I have a new Deore "shadow" rear mech on the way, and I figured why not put a new chain on it too since they had good ones for half off. I hate putting money into an older and un-special hardtail, I but at least once it's dialed in it'll be a good bike for years more.
  • cobba
    cobba Posts: 282
    kwsmithphoto wrote:
    I have a new Deore "shadow" rear mech on the way,

    What model?

    If it's the 592 it will work, if it's a 600/6000 series it won't work.
  • 02gf74
    02gf74 Posts: 1,168
    If the cassette is worn then a new chain will skip.

Categories